Fast Doesn’t Mean Careless: How AI Can Improve the Insurance Claims Experience
By Nicholas Johnson, Director of Technology, Big I New York
Insurance is built on trust. Your clients pay their premium, they read through their policy or more likely they trust you to walk them through it, and they hope they never actually have to use it. But when something goes wrong and a claim gets filed, that’s the moment their trust in the whole relationship gets tested. Not just their trust in the carrier, but their trust in you, the agent who sold them the policy and who they’re going to call the second something happens.
Artificial intelligence has real potential to make that experience better for your clients. But only if it’s implemented thoughtfully, with the right guardrails in place, and only if independent agents understand well enough how it works to keep advocating for their clients the way they always have.
Why This Matters to You as an Agent
You’re not the one processing claims. That’s the carrier’s job. But you are the one your client calls first when their basement floods or their car gets hit in a parking lot. You’re the one who has to explain why a claim is taking longer than expected, or why a payment came in lower than they hoped, or what their options are if they disagree with a decision. Whatever the carrier does on the back end becomes your problem the moment your client picks up the phone.
That’s exactly why it’s worth understanding how AI is changing claims handling. The more you understand about how these tools work and where they’re being used, the better positioned you are to set the right expectations with your clients up front, catch a problem before it becomes a complaint, and speak with confidence when a client asks you what’s actually happening behind the scenes.
AI Is Really Good at the Routine Stuff
A lot of claims are, honestly, pretty straightforward. Think windshield replacements, minor fender benders, small property losses, simple water damage claims, or any claim where liability is clear and the documentation is complete. These claims tend to follow predictable workflows with well established payment guidelines. There isn’t much ambiguity to work through, and there never really was much need for a human to sit and deliberate over them.
This is exactly the kind of work AI is well suited for. Rather than a claim sitting in a queue for days while it moves through multiple review steps, AI can read claim forms, pull information out of submitted documents, analyze photos, verify policy details, flag missing paperwork, estimate repair costs, and recommend a payment amount based on rules that are already established.
The important thing to understand here is that AI isn’t making up a decision on the fly. It’s accelerating work that was already highly standardized to begin with. It’s not thinking through a claim the way an adjuster would. It’s running the numbers on a claim that already had a fairly predictable answer, just faster than a person could.
For you and your agency, this is mostly good news. A client whose windshield claim gets processed in a day instead of a week is a client who stays happy with you, renews without a second thought, and doesn’t call your office three times asking for an update. Faster routine claims mean fewer service calls eating up your team’s time and more goodwill sitting in your book of business.
Speed Helps Everyone, Not Just the Policyholder
When routine claims move faster, the benefits show up across the board, and they ripple back to your agency in ways worth naming directly.
For your clients, it means getting paid sooner, waiting less, and getting better communication throughout a process that’s already stressful for most people. Nobody enjoys filing a claim, even when it goes smoothly, and a faster resolution goes a long way toward keeping their trust in the coverage you sold them.
For carriers, it means reduced administrative costs, shorter claim cycles, and more consistency in how similar claims get handled. That consistency matters to you too. A carrier that handles claims predictably and fairly is a carrier you can keep recommending with confidence.
For claims adjusters, I’d argue the benefit is the biggest of all. Instead of burning hours on routine claims that don’t really need their expertise, adjusters can spend their time on the claims that do: large losses, coverage disputes, complicated liability questions, potential fraud, and situations where a customer needs real help navigating a hard moment. AI doesn’t replace the adjuster. It just makes sure their expertise gets spent where it actually matters.
And for you as an agent, faster and more consistent claims handling means fewer fires to put out, fewer clients calling in frustrated, and more time to spend doing the parts of your job that actually grow your agency: writing new business, deepening relationships, and being the advisor your clients actually need you to be.
Human Judgment Still Has a Place
Not every claim fits neatly into a predefined process, and it probably never will. Some situations call for understanding unusual circumstances, interpreting policy language that isn’t black and white, weighing conflicting evidence, or just exercising the kind of judgment that comes from experience. Insurance has always involved more than checking boxes on a form. Every claim is a little different, and that won’t change just because the tools got smarter.
This is worth remembering when a client comes to you worried that a computer is going to decide their fate after a house fire or a serious accident. The reality is that AI is handling the simple, high volume, low ambiguity claims. The complicated ones, the ones that actually keep your clients up at night, are still going to a person with training and experience. Knowing that distinction, and being able to explain it clearly, is part of the value you bring as their agent.
Where I Think We Need to Be Careful
This is where the conversation shifts a bit, and it’s the part I think independent agents especially need to pay attention to. Approving a straightforward claim faster is one thing. Denying a claim is something else entirely.
A denial can carry real financial and emotional weight for a policyholder. It can also carry real reputational weight for you, since you’re the one who has to sit across the table, literally or figuratively, and help your client understand why. If AI plays a role in that outcome, carriers owe it to their customers, and frankly to the agents who sold the policy, to make sure a licensed claims professional reviews the recommendation, that the reasoning behind the decision can actually be explained in plain language, and that customers have a clear way to ask questions or appeal.
The goal should be AI assisted decision making, not AI only decision making. That distinction matters, and it’s a fair question to ask any carrier you represent. How is AI used in your claims process, and what does the appeal path look like when a client disagrees with a denial. Those aren’t unreasonable questions to bring to your carrier partners. If anything, asking them is part of doing right by your clients.
A Few Questions Worth Asking Your Carrier Partners
As these tools become more common, it’s worth having a short list of questions ready when you’re evaluating which carriers to place business with, or just staying informed about the ones you already represent:
Does AI ever have the final say on a denial, or is a licensed adjuster always in the loop?
Can the carrier explain, in plain language, why AI recommended a particular outcome?
What does the appeal process look like for a client who disagrees with an AI assisted decision?
How is client data being used and protected throughout this process?
You don’t need to become a technology expert to ask good questions. You just need to know enough to advocate for your clients the same way you always have.
Speed With Accountability
AI has enormous potential to improve how claims get handled. Used the right way, it can cut down on delays, improve customer satisfaction, and free up adjusters to focus on the claims that truly need a human being’s judgment. It can also free up your time as an agent to focus less on chasing claim statuses and more on the relationships that built your book of business in the first place.
But speed should never come at the cost of fairness.
The best version of this future isn’t one where technology replaces the people working in claims, or the agents standing beside their clients when things go wrong. It’s one where technology takes care of the routine work so experienced professionals, adjusters and agents alike, can spend their time where it counts most, on the people who need them.
Topics
